Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


Kiwix servers terminated by Hetzner - Page 3
New on LowEndTalk? Please Register and read our Community Rules.

All new Registrations are manually reviewed and approved, so a short delay after registration may occur before your account becomes active.

Kiwix servers terminated by Hetzner

135

Comments

  • allthemtingsallthemtings Member, Megathread Squad

    @maverick said:

    @allthemtings said:
    Your EX44 about to get choked slammed any day now @emgh

    he has diplomatic immunity now, they can't touch him... :D

    it s possibel

    Thanked by 3emgh Cybr maverick
  • @Advin said:
    It doesn't matter at the end of the day. The amount of money that they'd lose from a thread like this is inconsequential compared to the amount of revenue they have. To be considered big in Hetzner’s eyes, I assume you have to be in the €20,000+ per month range given that Hetzner is one of the largest server providers in Europe. I don’t think you even get an account manager or centralized point of contact even at €XX,XXX/month.

    Used to work for a company with that mindset. We are big, we can do what we want, plenty of customer knocking on our doors...

    And sure, they got away with a ton of less customer focused actions, like cutting back on support, increasing prices, delivering more and more sloppy product.

    But, there is always a but, ... they lose a client there, another there, those few issues becomes more issues. The reputation took small hits, nothing big, but those few hits started to becomes bigger because we lived in the age of the internet.

    It creates that type of spiral effect. It took YEARS before that effect really started to bite, management was so sure about their case. A few years later (think it took about 6 after i left), that promising company was a husk of itself.

    The fact that we see people being kicked more often, the insane amount of client refusals where too often its "you are from a bad country, we refuse you on the spot". You see that Hetzner is getting selective in their cliental, ... combined with a whole series of price increases in the last few years (and no, they even predate the whole corona/war situation, but those two have been convenient excuses).

    We shall see but dropping customers, values does not really matter, in the reputational sense. Google search remembers, and that is what most companies forget. I mean, look at iDrive and how posts going back years ago when they first started out still litter the internet. Reputation matters and stunts like we are seeing today are really not very good on that part.

    Thanked by 2network maverick
  • @loay said:
    I wondering if this is the reason, which is still common use case:
    https://www.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/1ha5qgk/comment/m18te00/

    • > Visits kiwix github repos
    • > Finds out they are using bot farm to scrape web content into Zim files
    • > Knows exactly why Hetzner cancelled their account
    • > Leaves this comment so you can sip your tea in peace

    Which repo has the "bot farm"? Their main product AFAIK is their Wikipedia dumps + offline reader.

  • they also closed my account after 3years without providing a reason (probably using too much bandwidth ig), moved to ovh, at least they gonna tell me why when i get kicked out, Right? Right?!

    Thanked by 2Cybr jsg
  • @network said:

    @loay said:
    I wondering if this is the reason, which is still common use case:
    https://www.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/1ha5qgk/comment/m18te00/

    • > Visits kiwix github repos
    • > Finds out they are using bot farm to scrape web content into Zim files
    • > Knows exactly why Hetzner cancelled their account
    • > Leaves this comment so you can sip your tea in peace

    Which repo has the "bot farm"? Their main product AFAIK is their Wikipedia dumps + offline reader.

    https://github.com/openzim/zimfarm
    https://zimit.kiwix.org/

    Thanked by 2network vicaya
  • @loay said:

    @network said:

    @loay said:
    I wondering if this is the reason, which is still common use case:
    https://www.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/1ha5qgk/comment/m18te00/

    • > Visits kiwix github repos
    • > Finds out they are using bot farm to scrape web content into Zim files
    • > Knows exactly why Hetzner cancelled their account
    • > Leaves this comment so you can sip your tea in peace

    Which repo has the "bot farm"? Their main product AFAIK is their Wikipedia dumps + offline reader.

    https://github.com/openzim/zimfarm
    https://zimit.kiwix.org/

    Am I reading that right? That form lets you request their bot to scrape any site?

  • @network said:

    @loay said:

    @network said:

    @loay said:
    I wondering if this is the reason, which is still common use case:
    https://www.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/1ha5qgk/comment/m18te00/

    • > Visits kiwix github repos
    • > Finds out they are using bot farm to scrape web content into Zim files
    • > Knows exactly why Hetzner cancelled their account
    • > Leaves this comment so you can sip your tea in peace

    Which repo has the "bot farm"? Their main product AFAIK is their Wikipedia dumps + offline reader.

    https://github.com/openzim/zimfarm
    https://zimit.kiwix.org/

    Am I reading that right? That form lets you request their bot to scrape any site?

    Yes, but I am not sure this was hosted on Hetzner.

  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad

    @allthemtings said:

    @maverick said:

    @allthemtings said:
    Your EX44 about to get choked slammed any day now @emgh

    he has diplomatic immunity now, they can't touch him... :D

    it s possibel

    My it s usage advanzing-1 for it s now

  • The only surprising thing is that they responded twice here, this company exists only for private trackers to push hundrerds of TBs. Only a brainless tard would host a serious project there

    Thanked by 1jsg
  • @johndeo983 said:
    The only surprising thing is that they responded twice here, this company exists only for private trackers to push hundrerds of TBs. Only a brainless tard would host a serious project there

    https://www.google.com/search?q=hetzner+kiwix

  • If this was a one time occurrence with a single client, then I'd give Hetzner the benefit of the doubt, but I've lost count of the number of stories just like this that I've come across at this point.

    It would be foolish to utilize Hetzner for anything serious, given their lengthy track record of randomly terminating clients for arbitrary reasons which they can't even be bothered to explain.

    Thanked by 2jsg z4r
  • NeoonNeoon Community Contributor, Veteran

    @Finisher said:
    they also closed my account after 3years without providing a reason (probably using too much bandwidth ig), moved to ovh, at least they gonna tell me why when i get kicked out, Right? Right?!

    Liability, if they don't give you a reason, gonna be hard for you to press any charges against Hetzner.

    Thanked by 1Cybr
  • Is there any other host that has anywhere this number of stories of banning customers?

    Thanked by 1jsg
  • @network said:
    Is there any other host that has anywhere this number of stories of banning customers?

    Not that that i am aware. We have hosts like contabo that are known oversellers, Strato kicking some people for misuse of their unlimited 1Gbit, some other hosts drama because of expired payments or lacking support. Netcup maybe for rejecting users but nowhere near the levels of Hetzner.

    For the most part its mostly Hetzner that seems to generates more drama with public know terminations and rejecting users. Its also noticeable because there are some rather high paying customer terminations. I understand Hetzner is big but they are not that big compared to some other companies, especially given the more noise they generate.

    This situation feels a bit like Plex... In a effort to "clean up their act" to be more presentable, they have gone into overdrive against anything what they perceive as less palatable (ironically).

    It really feels like if you use Hetzner, you need to proxy your actual content behind different providers, yes, that includes 100% legal content, just to avoid some unknown complaints to be considered a TOS breakage.

    Let see:

    • Use too much CPU power is reason to be terminated (cryptominers, but its not just limited to them). You pay for a resource but if you use it to 100%, that is grounds for termination.
    • Use too much HDDs is a reason to be terminated (again, crypto miners) but you get the point.
    • Use too much bandwidth is also reason to be terminated (unless you pay for it? But it seem to be a issue on those 1Gbit servers, probably why we never see 2.5Gbit)
    • Illegal stuff (sure, but it seems that even fake DMCA claims or those that not apply can result in termination)
    • Scraping, again, not illegal! That is also a reason for being terminated.
    • Payment method expired, some drama, termination.
    • Doing anything that can be considered a disturbance to other VMs (this one is very broad).
    • ...

    That is just stuff i can remember from the last 2 years. It comes down to it that Hetzner mostly wants good little housefathers (is that the right term?), that do not use too much resources. And if you proxy your content over somebody else, they do not care. Its only if there is a link back to them, then its when they get all "terminator" (see the reputation buildup issue). Anything beyond this seems to be more "how big of a payer are you again?". Que drama.

  • @allthemtings said:

    @allthemtings said:

    @Advin said:
    We are looking to move our colocation racks for similar reasons and we've already cancelled almost all of our dedicated servers and cloud compute with them. Hetzner is not really friendly to resellers like us. I don't want to have to be in a situation where I need to move an entire rack of equipment within 30 days because Hetzner suddenly decides that we aren't a suitable client for them. No other colocation datacenter would do something similar.

    I've seen other hosting providers get terminated with a 30-day notice to get out. It really sucks when I've seen providers pay $X,XXX monthly, and then receive one of these notices. Hetzner will not work with you at all and will never give you a reason. If it is because of large amounts of traffic or incompatibility in business models, then they should just say that.

    Imagine if they booted a provider such as @labze the trickle down would be catastrophic, huge damage - Ive seen several huge spenders booted off Hetzner without a real reason and given a 30 day window to move everything off....again without a real reason

    It’s not my business to name but pixeldrain publicly stated multiple times he was booted from hetzner without a real reason and he had hundreds of servers and multiple PB of data he had to move off within a unrealistic 30 day window…that’s a tens of thousands of dollars per month customer and that’s how he got treated. Do you think they care about your 1/2 100€ server?

    https://pixeldrain.com/d/CvVnxWME

  • edited December 2024

    @ralf said:
    You're assuming that they were banned due to bandwidth rather than the questionable content. Previous times Hetzner have cancelled people for excessive bandwidth, they've told people and given a month to leave rather than being immediately cancelled.

    Who the fuck cancels customers if they go over bandwidth limits? You simply contact the customer and ask to pay the price per TB if it goes over X limit. Most of providers I used will just bill you separately for over usage and have automated messages in case you go over 90% of the limit.

  • Wow. Absolutely ridiculous.

    Thanked by 2darkimmortal emgh
  • atulatul Member
    edited December 2024

    they are the new OVH in terms of support and service and quality of hardware on their server. They replace hardware with another that is not any better than the previous ones. I had 2 hard disk replaced back in 2019 within 3 months. Every new server had a hard disk failure, network card issue right from 3-4 months onwards.

    Problem is people don't read reviews before buying.

    here if someone wants to read about their support.

    https://www.trustpilot.com/review/hetzner.com?sort=recency

  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad

    @Finisher said:

    @allthemtings said:

    @allthemtings said:

    @Advin said:
    We are looking to move our colocation racks for similar reasons and we've already cancelled almost all of our dedicated servers and cloud compute with them. Hetzner is not really friendly to resellers like us. I don't want to have to be in a situation where I need to move an entire rack of equipment within 30 days because Hetzner suddenly decides that we aren't a suitable client for them. No other colocation datacenter would do something similar.

    I've seen other hosting providers get terminated with a 30-day notice to get out. It really sucks when I've seen providers pay $X,XXX monthly, and then receive one of these notices. Hetzner will not work with you at all and will never give you a reason. If it is because of large amounts of traffic or incompatibility in business models, then they should just say that.

    Imagine if they booted a provider such as @labze the trickle down would be catastrophic, huge damage - Ive seen several huge spenders booted off Hetzner without a real reason and given a 30 day window to move everything off....again without a real reason

    It’s not my business to name but pixeldrain publicly stated multiple times he was booted from hetzner without a real reason and he had hundreds of servers and multiple PB of data he had to move off within a unrealistic 30 day window…that’s a tens of thousands of dollars per month customer and that’s how he got treated. Do you think they care about your 1/2 100€ server?

    https://pixeldrain.com/d/CvVnxWME

    wow this is literally clueless

    trying to beat OVH support are we :D

    Thanked by 3maverick Cybr Voltrina
  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad
    edited December 2024

    "hi its legit traffic this is what im doing"

    "we see it as an attack"

    :D

    Thanked by 1Cybr
  • @Finisher said:

    @allthemtings said:
    It’s not my business to name but pixeldrain publicly stated multiple times he was booted from hetzner without a real reason and he had hundreds of servers and multiple PB of data he had to move off within a unrealistic 30 day window…that’s a tens of thousands of dollars per month customer and that’s how he got treated. Do you think they care about your 1/2 100€ server?

    https://pixeldrain.com/d/CvVnxWME

    Sorry, but this just shows that pixeldrain people really don't know what they are doing though. Hetzner's response seems reasonable in this case:


    ---- Hetzner:

    Dear Client,

    Please tune your server and if this happen again please provide an reply on abuse ticket.

    we have unlocked the servers now.

    ---- Pixeldrain:

    Thanks..

    There were two problems with the abuse tickets.
    First is that the original abuse notification arrived at 1 AM, and when I started checking my mail for the day all the servers were already locked.
    And second is that your system sent me like 200 mails at once. How do I even reply to that? Responding to all of that would take more time than I have.

    The notifications also said that the case would be manually checked. I had hoped that the person checking the tickets would realize that the system had made a mistake and discard the tickets.

    I find it troubling that such impactful descisions are made by an automated system. This does not put me at ease at all. I have been a very content customer for over five years, I have paid nearly as much for my Hetzner servers as the house I live in. Most of that trust is gone now. I'm keeping my eyes open for alternatives.

    This has caused so many problems. My database has gotten corrupted because half of the servers suddenly disappeared. I need to repair that. I have a dozen support mails from angry customers to answer.

    ---- Hetzner:

    Dear Client,

    please reduce or control the traffic on your server to avoid such abuse.

    Thanked by 1mrTom
  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad

    @vicaya said: Sorry, but this just shows that pixeldrain people really don't know what they are doing though. Hetzner's response seems reasonable in this case:

    You're not baiting me brah

    Thanked by 1TheGreatOakley
  • @Finisher said:

    @allthemtings said:

    @allthemtings said:

    @Advin said:
    We are looking to move our colocation racks for similar reasons and we've already cancelled almost all of our dedicated servers and cloud compute with them. Hetzner is not really friendly to resellers like us. I don't want to have to be in a situation where I need to move an entire rack of equipment within 30 days because Hetzner suddenly decides that we aren't a suitable client for them. No other colocation datacenter would do something similar.

    I've seen other hosting providers get terminated with a 30-day notice to get out. It really sucks when I've seen providers pay $X,XXX monthly, and then receive one of these notices. Hetzner will not work with you at all and will never give you a reason. If it is because of large amounts of traffic or incompatibility in business models, then they should just say that.

    Imagine if they booted a provider such as @labze the trickle down would be catastrophic, huge damage - Ive seen several huge spenders booted off Hetzner without a real reason and given a 30 day window to move everything off....again without a real reason

    It’s not my business to name but pixeldrain publicly stated multiple times he was booted from hetzner without a real reason and he had hundreds of servers and multiple PB of data he had to move off within a unrealistic 30 day window…that’s a tens of thousands of dollars per month customer and that’s how he got treated. Do you think they care about your 1/2 100€ server?

    https://pixeldrain.com/d/CvVnxWME

    The replies are very weird,maybe some type of abuse detection ai with an non native english speaker? Or an non technical person just reading off a set reply-procedure that they don't understand.

    Thanked by 1emgh
  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad

    @wadhah said: an non technical person just reading off a set reply-procedure that they don't understand

    probably this

    Thanked by 1Cybr
  • What PixelDrain hosts and transmits is anything but legit.....

  • stefemanstefeman Member
    edited December 2024

    Oh, its this thread again. Imagine going from 20TB limit to unlimited and then banning everyone exceeding that old 20TB limit.

    I still have one dedicated server and small backup box with hetzner, but im working to move it all to local unraid and ovhcloud. Hopefully im free next month.

    Long time Finnish customer btw.

    Vittu te olette surkeita. Pilaatte suomalaisten providerien maineen.

    Tagging @PulsedMedia because they are better alternative locally despite being so much smaller. Imagine lol.

    Thanked by 3allthemtings jsg z4r
  • NeoonNeoon Community Contributor, Veteran

    @stefeman said:
    Oh, its this thread again. Imagine going from 20TB limit to unlimited and then banning everyone exceeding that old 20TB limit.

    Nah, they added a zero at least.

  • @CyberneticTitan said:
    What PixelDrain hosts and transmits is anything but legit.....

    Quite the opposite. PixelDrain is the most christian file host of them all.

  • @emgh said:
    "hi its legit traffic this is what im doing"

    "we see it as an attack"

    :D

    Don't forget they didn't just say they see it as an attack, but even claimed the traffic was due to "mining". Lmao

    Thanked by 2lukast__ emgh
  • @johndeo983 said:
    The only surprising thing is that they responded twice here, this company exists only for private trackers to push hundrerds of TBs. Only a brainless tard would host a serious project there

    can confirm none of my personal seedboxes at hetzner seeding stupid amounts of data for private trackers has ever been cancelled.

    Thanked by 1raindog308
Sign In or Register to comment.