Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


SendGrid/SES vs Dedicated server - Page 2
New on LowEndTalk? Please Register and read our Community Rules.

All new Registrations are manually reviewed and approved, so a short delay after registration may occur before your account becomes active.

SendGrid/SES vs Dedicated server

2

Comments

  • jarjar Patron Provider, Top Host, Veteran

    Francisco said: I always assumed that there was paid whitelisting with the big senders

    I'm fairly confident there are some things like that going on between the big players.

  • gestiondbigestiondbi Member, Patron Provider

    I know companies that pay or have a bidirectional relationship to not get listed......

    Thanked by 1vimalware
  • GulfGulf Member
    edited November 2017

    This is my thread, it is a bit old, but I have some questions.

    I played with own server, I configured it properly, after 1000 emails, IP goes to the Spamhaus. The same email volume from Sendgrid goes to the inbox.

    1. What is the difference between sendgrid IP and dedicated IP. Does SendGrid certify theis IPs somewhere or really pay providers?

    2. Do you think Gmail and other mailboxes really track the proder associated with IP (Hetzner, Online.net, etc)? If Gmail receives email from Sendgrid IP, they trust it because it is Sendgrid. Is it possible?

  • 1) You're asking "What's the difference between a paid-for, managed service that ensures delivery, and running something I don't really have that knowledge to do myself."

    Long story short, unless you are incredibly proactive, if someone doesn't want your mail, you're going to get listed somewhere. It helps to know basic DKIM/etc protocols, ensuring all host settings are proper to "actual service" standards, and so forth.

    2) Yes.

  • jarjar Patron Provider, Top Host, Veteran
    edited November 2017

    Gulf said: What is the difference between sendgrid IP and dedicated IP. Does SendGrid certify theis IPs somewhere or really pay providers?

    Well known for handling abuse, preventing abuse, and having large corporate contacts that can penetrate the support barriers where people like you and I get stuck. There's also warming up IPs and knowing how recipient providers like to receive email. For example, open 1,000 simultaneous SMTP connections with another provider to deliver 1,000 messages at the exact same time, from the same IP, and you can forget about being able to email them. You get to know these things from trial and error, studying, and never sleeping.

    There's a reason they charge good money, it's not 99% profit. It's expensive to run, maintain, and keep talented people employed.

    Seriously though if 1,000 emails landed you on spamhaus, you're sending spam. Stop it.

    Thanked by 3Gulf Falzo vimalware
  • @Gulf said:
    This is my thread, it is a bit old, but I have some questions.

    I played with own server, I configured it properly, after 1000 emails, IP goes to the Spamhaus. The same email volume from Sendgrid goes to the inbox.

    1. What is the difference between sendgrid IP and dedicated IP. Does SendGrid certify theis IPs somewhere or really pay providers?

    2. Do you think Gmail and other mailboxes really track the proder associated with IP (Hetzner, Online.net, etc)? If Gmail receives email from Sendgrid IP, they trust it because it is Sendgrid. Is it possible?

    Email providers like sendgrid send ALOT OF MAIL. Your ip sends maybe a fraction of that. Doesn't matter if your mail server is properly configured because the legitimate volume coming from sendgrid like providers make it easier to enter the indox vs junk folder.

  • GulfGulf Member
    edited November 2017

    @jarland said:

    There's a reason they charge good money, it's not 99% profit. It's expensive to run, maintain, and keep talented people employed.

    My current volume at SendGrid is 7 000 000 emails per month. And I pay around 2500$. Looking for cheaper solution.

    Seriously though if 1,000 emails landed you on spamhaus, you're sending spam. Stop it.

    I do not send any spam. Maybe misconfigured somehow or bad IP (OVH or LeaseWeb, do not remember, it was 1 year ago).

  • needavpsneedavps Member
    edited November 2017

    opps. sorry. dunno why doubled.

  • jarjar Patron Provider, Top Host, Veteran

    needavps said: Email providers like sendgrid send ALOT OF MAIL. Your ip sends maybe a fraction of that. Doesn't matter if your mail server is properly configured because the legitimate volume coming from sendgrid like providers make it easier to enter the indox vs junk folder.

    This is true. Also reminds me of another good point. So many large corporations use SendGrid. If Hotmail blocks SendGrid tomorrow, how many complaints do you think they'll receive? Not to mention social media pressure and potentially news stories.

    But if they block one of us, meh. Best we get is upvoted in a comment section somewhere.

  • jarjar Patron Provider, Top Host, Veteran

    Gulf said: My current volume at SendGrid is 7 000 000 emails per month. And I pay around 2500$. Looking for cheaper solution.

    At that point you should probably have your own IP space and have enough corporate weight to throw around that the major providers should cower in fear of upsetting you and your customers.

  • Gulf said: My current volume at SendGrid is 7 000 000 emails per month. And I pay around 2500$. Looking for cheaper solution.

    If your profits don't cover $0.0003/email maybe it's more rational to think about raising your margins instead of cutting loses? Just a thought.

  • GulfGulf Member
    edited November 2017

    @jarland said:
    Seriously though if 1,000 emails landed you on spamhaus, you're sending spam. Stop it.

    Emails delivered by SendGrid, go to inbox. From own server to spamhaus after around 1,000-10,000 emais. Maybe misconfigured.

  • @Yura said:

    If your profits don't cover $0.0003/email maybe it's more rational to think about raising your margins instead of cutting loses? Just a thought.

    Yep, sendgrid is expensive at this point. I spend 3k on emails, sms and hosting, and earn 9k. Additional 1k would be useful :)

  • @Gulf said:

    @Yura said:

    If your profits don't cover $0.0003/email maybe it's more rational to think about raising your margins instead of cutting loses? Just a thought.

    Yep, sendgrid is expensive at this point. I spend 3k on emails, sms and hosting, and earn 9k. Additional 1k would be useful :)

    honestly if you had been paying sendgrid just to have 0 opened/ 0 clicked on emails than you probably would save just managing your own email servers.

    Thanked by 1WSS
  • @Gulf, you have 0.00% opened and clicked. Not even one. Is that ok for you? :)

  • @needavps said:
    honestly if you had been paying sendgrid just to have 0 opened/ 0 clicked on emails than you probably would save just managing your own email servers.

  • @needavps said:

    honestly if you had been paying sendgrid just to have 0 opened/ 0 clicked on emails than you probably would save just managing your own email servers.

    I just disabled this feature. This hurts deliverability, email providers do not love remote images in emails, especially companies. Also email clients like Thunderbird block all images and styles if they see remote image.

    Thanked by 1Yura
  • @Gulf said:

    @needavps said:

    honestly if you had been paying sendgrid just to have 0 opened/ 0 clicked on emails than you probably would save just managing your own email servers.

    I just disabled this feature. This hurts deliverability, email providers do not love remote images in emails, especially companies. Also email clients like Thunderbird block all images and styles if they see remote image.

    ... I think you are using a tracking method in sendgrid that I am not familiar with...

  • GulfGulf Member
    edited November 2017

    @needavps said:
    ... I think you are using a tracking method in sendgrid that I am not familiar with...

    All email providers use very simple tracking method. They just add a tiny 1 pixel image in the body of email. Like:
    <img style="visibility:hidden" src="sendgrid.com/track/opended-email-id/hash23wrwwwrerw" />

    When user opens an email, browsers loads this image and sendgrid, mailgun, etc can track an ip, country, browser and etc.

    Gmail protects users from tracking by loading these images from their servers, so you will always see US, Mountain View in your reports.

    But companies may reject email with remote images or lower your scores.

  • @Gulf said:
    But companies may reject email with remote images or lower your scores.

    Clickthrough is still pretty much hardcoded in, however. No views and no clickthroughs?

  • needavpsneedavps Member
    edited November 2017

    @Gulf said:

    @needavps said:
    ... I think you are using a tracking method in sendgrid that I am not familiar with...

    All email providers use very simple tracking method. They just add a tiny 1 pixel image in the body of email. Like:
    <img style="visibility:hidden" src="sendgrid.com/track/opended-email-id/hash23wrwwwrerw" />

    When user opens an email, browsers loads this image and sendgrid, mailgun, etc can track a ip, country, browser and etc.

    Gmail protect users from tracking by loading these images from their services, so you will always see US, Mountain View in your reports.

    But companies may reject email with remote images or lower your scores.

    ... 1 pixel tracking was something that might have been done 10 years ago. I do not believe this is the tracking method in sendgrid or mailgun in the last few years...

  • @needavps said:

    ... 1 pixel tracking was something that might have been done 10 years ago. I do not believe this is the tracking method in sendgrid or mailgun in the last few years...

    If they could reinvent email...

  • @WSS said:
    Clickthrough is still pretty much hardcoded in, however. No views and no clickthroughs?

    I do not put any links in emails, except unsubscription. Hard to explain, just an online service.

  • We send over 10 million emails per month. Sendgrid became expensive eventually, even though with such high plans they usually offer discounts and assign a customer support person on Skype.

    Aws SES does the same, they assign a dedi tech support, however based on personal experience, the dedi support is as useless as an ejection seat on a helicopter.

    We tried a dedi server, its not as cost efficient as you might think, you need someone to daily monitor the IPs reputation, you need to warm up the IPs, if you wanna send emails quickly, you're gonna need powerMTA and that's not cheap unless you get a null version. You will also need a software like Interspire email marketing, then you need its plugins like the multi-threading addon because they are a bunch of assholes and can't put it all in one software. You will need rdns spf dkim, you have to handle bounces and unsubs. Assuming you have a site You need to connect it through APIs.

    We're currently using emarays, though the open rate is lower than sendgrid and mailchimp but it ain't bad.

    There's appsumo, they seem hella cheap compared to others, I personally haven't tried them yet, but they seem ok

    Thanked by 1Gulf
  • needavps said: 1 pixel tracking was something that might have been done 10 years ago. I do not believe this is the tracking method in sendgrid or mailgun in the last few years...

    But it still works. Google (sort of) killed it with their proxy, but that only renders location data useless as Google still requests the image at the date/time user opened the email.

  • @Gulf said:

    @needavps said:

    ... 1 pixel tracking was something that might have been done 10 years ago. I do not believe this is the tracking method in sendgrid or mailgun in the last few years...

    If they could reinvent email...

    my bad. I do see that in the sendgrid account section. Good luck with your decision!

  • @Hybrid said:
    they usually offer discounts and assign a customer support person on Skype.

    The same situation. What discount do they offer with a good upfront payment (for example 1500$)?

  • oneilonlineoneilonline Member, Host Rep

    1.4m emails and ZERO opened or clicked!?! LOL What else can this be besides spam? Looks like it's auto sorted to the junk/spam folder.

  • GulfGulf Member
    edited November 2017

    @needavps said:

    my bad. I do see that in the sendgrid account section. Good luck with your decision!

    Tested many times. Yes it would be good to remove some inactive emails, but companies reject such mails. Unfortunately Sendgrid does not offer a way to send tracking only for public email providers like gmail, yahoo. So I could choose where I would like to send this tracking image...

  • oneilonline said: 1.4m emails and ZERO opened or clicked!?! LOL What else can this be besides spam? Looks like it's auto sorted to the junk/spam folder.

    indeed what stupid post could yours be besides spam? read the rest of the thread.

    Thanked by 1Gulf
Sign In or Register to comment.