Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


Shells Virtual Desktop
BMail.ag - Secure Email Service
Server.net
CPLicense.net
VPS Server
Buy VPN
Vultr
VMs for AI
HostDare
ReliableSite White-Label Dedicated Hosting for Resellers
InterServer VPS
BMail.ag - Secure Email Service
Best VPN
High-Performance Bare Metal Server Solutions
Karvl.com
Server Mania Cloud Hosting
DataWagon Hosting
AlphaVPS Hosting
Evoxt.com
Clouvider
VPS Hosting with NVMe
Residential IPs in the US & 4G Mobile Proxies in EU & US with Unlimited Bandwidth
ReliableSite White-Label Dedicated Hosting for Resellers
Rabisu - Hosting Solutions
Shells Virtual Desktop
New on LowEndTalk? Please Register and read our Community Rules.

All new Registrations are manually reviewed and approved, so a short delay after registration may occur before your account becomes active.

Normal to charge for bandwidth between two boxes? (not public egress)

2

Comments

  • qpsqps Member, Host Rep

    @BlaZe said: Tagging @qps as they have Ashburn dedicated servers: https://quickpacket.com/billing/store/dedicated-servers-ashburn

    Thanks - we're happy to help @casey7398. However, QuickPacket also measures bandwidth usage at the public switch port level for the servers where we meter bandwidth usage. Our intention is not to bill for internal traffic, but this is just the easiest way for us to meter. We are willing to connect the second NIC of the server(s) either to each other (in the case of two servers in the same data center) or to a private network switch port, where traffic is free, and we can put all of a customer's servers private network ports in a private VLAN. Lots of options with how this is all setup and we're very willing to do custom things! Most of this setup can be done for free or low cost.

    We also have many configurations available beyond those listed on our site, and we're happy to build something custom to meet a customer requirement.

    Please feel free to DM me to discuss further, or I'm also available on Discord (user qps), or other chat platforms if you prefer one of those.

  • ezethezeth Member, Host Rep
    edited June 2024

    @mikewazar said: Industry standard is charging for a private VLAN between a customers servers for internal traffic on request.

    Idk.

    For our dedicated server customers we give everyone their own VLAN with a subnet attached.

    They get 40 Gbps LAN traffic between all their servers and 250 Mbps 95th on 10 Gbps public port.

    We only monitor the outgoing port, LAN traffic is unlimited.

  • You're 0 for 2 on LowEndHosts. Perhaps there is a reason why you pay companies like AWS more to host your critical infrastructure.

    Ever heard of opportunity cost?

    Thanked by 1sasslik
  • I guess so! I suppose I didnt realize just how low end some of the providers are here! o3o

    Thanked by 1sasslik
  • LeviLevi Member

    What bothers me the most - the lack of automation. Is it not normal for large dedi or vps providers to auto provision internal IP? It is normal to assume that big clients will order multiple servers and will want interconnect between them. It is so primitive to charge extra for vlan.

    Thanked by 1sasslik
  • mwmw Member

    @ezeth said:

    @mikewazar said: Industry standard is charging for a private VLAN between a customers servers for internal traffic on request.

    Idk.

    For our dedicated server customers we give everyone their own VLAN with a subnet attached.

    They get 40 Gbps LAN traffic between all their servers and 250 Mbps 95th on 10 Gbps public port.

    We only monitor the outgoing port, LAN traffic is unlimited.

    You -as standard- offer 40Gbit internally to "everyone"?

  • ezethezeth Member, Host Rep

    @mikewazar said:

    @ezeth said:

    @mikewazar said: Industry standard is charging for a private VLAN between a customers servers for internal traffic on request.

    Idk.

    For our dedicated server customers we give everyone their own VLAN with a subnet attached.

    They get 40 Gbps LAN traffic between all their servers and 250 Mbps 95th on 10 Gbps public port.

    We only monitor the outgoing port, LAN traffic is unlimited.

    You -as standard- offer 40Gbit internally to "everyone"?

    Yes, everyone gets it.

    Offering 40Gbit private uplink is not more expensive than your standard 1 / 10 Gbps tbh. To give you a feel for pricing.

    One may buy something like: https://www.arista.com/assets/data/pdf/Datasheets/7050QX-32_32S_Datasheet.pdf. It's a 40G datacenter switch. Current pricing on Ebay is 200 USD

    For the servers themselves you need a NIC + QSPF cable. It costs 25 USD each per server:

    For 40G NIC + QSPF pricing, based on last purchase:
    (Lot of 5) Amphenol QSFP 3M Cable 038-004-067-01 UNUSED #95
    US $32.00 / $6.4 each

    Mellanox MCX314A-BCCT 40GB 2-Port QSFP+ PCI-E Low Profile
    Quantity : 3
    US $44.97 / $14.99 each

  • mwmw Member

    @ezeth said:

    @mikewazar said:

    @ezeth said:

    @mikewazar said: Industry standard is charging for a private VLAN between a customers servers for internal traffic on request.

    Idk.

    For our dedicated server customers we give everyone their own VLAN with a subnet attached.

    They get 40 Gbps LAN traffic between all their servers and 250 Mbps 95th on 10 Gbps public port.

    We only monitor the outgoing port, LAN traffic is unlimited.

    You -as standard- offer 40Gbit internally to "everyone"?

    Yes, everyone gets it.

    Offering 40Gbit private uplink is not more expensive than your standard 1 / 10 Gbps tbh. To give you a feel for pricing.

    One may buy something like: https://www.arista.com/assets/data/pdf/Datasheets/7050QX-32_32S_Datasheet.pdf. It's a 40G datacenter switch. Current pricing on Ebay is 200 USD

    For the servers themselves you need a NIC + QSPF cable. It costs 25 USD each per server:

    For 40G NIC + QSPF pricing, based on last purchase:
    (Lot of 5) Amphenol QSFP 3M Cable 038-004-067-01 UNUSED #95
    US $32.00 / $6.4 each

    Mellanox MCX314A-BCCT 40GB 2-Port QSFP+ PCI-E Low Profile
    Quantity : 3
    US $44.97 / $14.99 each

    If you’re offering 40G as standard, you are absolutely not industry norm lmao but god damn, who do you represent? would love to look at your configurations

  • yoursunnyyoursunny Member, IPv6 Advocate

    Technically strong developer uses 100Gbps private network.
    40Gbps is for weaklings.

    Thanked by 4mw ezeth coolice sasslik
  • Tier.net was able to come through and get us exactly what we needed! Unmetered, direct interconnects, immediate deployment and fair pricing. Great service and would recommend highly!

    Thanked by 2Levi OhJohn
  • ezethezeth Member, Host Rep
    edited June 2024

    @yoursunny said: Technically strong developer uses 100Gbps private network.

    I have considered getting 100 Gbps. I like low-cost so I'd get https://www.ebay.com/itm/196385918913. I only see 100 Gbps being useful in an all nvme Ceph storage cluster :D
    For public internet anything higher than 10 Gbps is a waste. It's not like all the mirrors, GitHub etc have higher than 10G anyway.

  • trewqtrewq Administrator, Patron Provider

    @Levi said:
    What bothers me the most - the lack of automation. Is it not normal for large dedi or vps providers to auto provision internal IP? It is normal to assume that big clients will order multiple servers and will want interconnect between them. It is so primitive to charge extra for vlan.

    It’s not actually that common that people want private connectivity between their servers. It’s for sure a sales discussions as it incurs extra cost to provide.

    Thanked by 1Clouvider
  • VexeliaVexelia Member
    edited June 2024

    @casey7398 said:
    Guys we can drop it. I am not sure what happened to be honest, but something spooked them about our needs I guess. We are a SaaS provider for trading software; with big inter facility bandwidth needs (moving exchange data between our services) and need 10gbps ports with low latency between all of our microservices.

    It's all good - there are other providers out there. I am glad this happened now though and not 10 months from now when 100,000 traders were on the machines! ha

    If NJ/NYC works for you, @RoyaleHosting might be able to meet your connectivity needs.​

  • RoyaleHostingRoyaleHosting Member, Patron Provider
    edited June 2024

    @Vexelia said:

    @casey7398 said:
    Guys we can drop it. I am not sure what happened to be honest, but something spooked them about our needs I guess. We are a SaaS provider for trading software; with big inter facility bandwidth needs (moving exchange data between our services) and need 10gbps ports with low latency between all of our microservices.

    It's all good - there are other providers out there. I am glad this happened now though and not 10 months from now when 100,000 traders were on the machines! ha

    If NJ/NYC works for you, @RoyaleHosting might be able to meet your connectivity needs.​

    Thank you for the mention!

    We would be happy to help out, if OP could email us at [email protected] we can look into the options :)

  • mwmw Member

    i still want to know who @ezeth reps

  • yoursunnyyoursunny Member, IPv6 Advocate

    @mikewazar said:
    i still want to know who @ezeth reps

    Boomer host, a provider that offered $5/year OpenVZ containers with massive overselling and monthlong downtime.

    Thanked by 1mw
  • I'm confused as to why the problem is so big. I think he was just asking about "industry standards" and had no intention of cornering the provider.

    Thanked by 1darkimmortal
  • SillyGooseSillyGoose Member
    edited June 2024

    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

  • @SillyGoose said:
    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

    Is there such thing as a metered private network?

  • LeviLevi Member

    @BruhGamer12 said:

    @SillyGoose said:
    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

    Is there such thing as a metered private network?

    Of course! As well as serup fee for vlan.

  • @BruhGamer12 said:

    @SillyGoose said:
    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

    Is there such thing as a metered private network?

    If I'm correct that's what OP is saying. They are charging him for bandwidth between those servers.

  • SGrafSGraf Member, Patron Provider
    edited June 2024

    @SillyGoose said:

    @BruhGamer12 said:

    @SillyGoose said:
    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

    Is there such thing as a metered private network?

    If I'm correct that's what OP is saying. They are charging him for bandwidth between those servers.

    What OP was saying is that his server provider (clouvider), like most small/medium server providers meters bandwidth at the switch-port. This is pretty much the "industry standard" for lack of better wording. This also means it is not easily possible to differentiate between internal and external bandwidth/traffic.

    OP assumed that the Provider of his choice would automatically differentiate between "bandwidth between servers" and "transit". Then there was a big surprise when they discovered that the advertised "data transfer" is regardless of destination (local or via transit).

    So this situation would have unfolded exactly the same way across most providers here.

    From this thread we know that the customer was informed about the option to get a private network (that would not be metered like the "uplink port" of the server(s)) - However we do not know what the pricing would have been.

    Personally i think with most reasonable and good providers here, its not an issue to get a second network drop/link to connect multiple servers you have with them in the same dc/location.

    @BruhGamer12 said:

    @SillyGoose said:
    Mainly private networking is one-time fee and usually unmetered, there are no industry standard thing. It's all on provider.

    Is there such thing as a metered private network?

    I can think of a number of examples where that could be the case and make sense.
    However most of these cases involve services that the "lowend" service providers typically don't offer.

    For example "E-Line" / "E-Lan", MPLS type of services, ...think... "private networking" between different physical locations (maybe even in different cities/countries). Those would either be "port cap/limit" (hardware, or via shaper/policier for bandwith limitation) or could be billed 95th percentile / burstable ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burstable_billing ).

    For MyRootPW as an example i can offer a private network/L2 type of service that spans Vienna to Amsterdam with different termination points.....

  • sunnygsunnyg Member
    edited June 2024

    Having used numerous large hosts, only seen Hetzner offering unlimited internal traffic on their 10GE links.

    Thanked by 1sasslik
  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad

    @fluffernutter said:

    @casey7398 said:

    Honestly I am not sure how anything in my post was out of line and I think you took much to offense to my posting. I simply asked a question to see if this was standard practice in the industry? The more you go down the rabbit hole, the worse this is making you look...

    they used to be really touchy back when they posted here more, behaving like this is pretty on brand for them. I just thought they improved in the past years, but I guess not. like you said, good thing you found this out before moving everything over.

    Yes, they were. Very edgy and sometimes downright mean. They then took a pause, came back, and seemed better. This was a disappointment.

    Thanked by 2fluffernutter sh97
  • mwmw Member

    @sunnyg said:
    Having used numerous large hosts, only seen Hetzner offering unlimited traffic on their 10GE links.

    “Unlimited” billed at €1/TB :)

  • sunnygsunnyg Member

    @mikewazar said:

    @sunnyg said:
    Having used numerous large hosts, only seen Hetzner offering unlimited traffic on their 10GE links.

    “Unlimited” billed at €1/TB :)

    Sorry meant internal (hetzner to hetzner)

  • @emgh said:

    @fluffernutter said:

    @casey7398 said:

    Honestly I am not sure how anything in my post was out of line and I think you took much to offense to my posting. I simply asked a question to see if this was standard practice in the industry? The more you go down the rabbit hole, the worse this is making you look...

    they used to be really touchy back when they posted here more, behaving like this is pretty on brand for them. I just thought they improved in the past years, but I guess not. like you said, good thing you found this out before moving everything over.

    Yes, they were. Very edgy and sometimes downright mean. They then took a pause, came back, and seemed better. This was a disappointment.

    I really hoped they'd end up being more mature, I know I definitely make a point to avoid dealing with them due to their behavior and I'm sure a lot of other serious customers do the same.

    Thanked by 1emgh
  • emghemgh Member, Megathread Squad
    edited June 2024

    @fluffernutter said:

    @emgh said:

    @fluffernutter said:

    @casey7398 said:

    Honestly I am not sure how anything in my post was out of line and I think you took much to offense to my posting. I simply asked a question to see if this was standard practice in the industry? The more you go down the rabbit hole, the worse this is making you look...

    they used to be really touchy back when they posted here more, behaving like this is pretty on brand for them. I just thought they improved in the past years, but I guess not. like you said, good thing you found this out before moving everything over.

    Yes, they were. Very edgy and sometimes downright mean. They then took a pause, came back, and seemed better. This was a disappointment.

    I really hoped they'd end up being more mature, I know I definitely make a point to avoid dealing with them due to their behavior and I'm sure a lot of other serious customers do the same.

    Definitely, and it’s sad because this forum needs to keep on having a fair amount of knowledgable and serious long-term providers to compensate for the come-and-go providers.

    I sometimes feel Clouvider belongs to the serious kind but it seems it’s always a question of time until I’m proven wrong.

    Thanked by 1sh97
  • @emgh said:

    @fluffernutter said:

    @emgh said:

    @fluffernutter said:

    @casey7398 said:

    Honestly I am not sure how anything in my post was out of line and I think you took much to offense to my posting. I simply asked a question to see if this was standard practice in the industry? The more you go down the rabbit hole, the worse this is making you look...

    they used to be really touchy back when they posted here more, behaving like this is pretty on brand for them. I just thought they improved in the past years, but I guess not. like you said, good thing you found this out before moving everything over.

    Yes, they were. Very edgy and sometimes downright mean. They then took a pause, came back, and seemed better. This was a disappointment.

    I really hoped they'd end up being more mature, I know I definitely make a point to avoid dealing with them due to their behavior and I'm sure a lot of other serious customers do the same.

    Definitely, and it’s sad because this forum needs to keep on having a fair amount of knowledgable and serious long-term providers to compensate for the come-and-go providers.

    I sometimes feel Clouvider belongs to the serious kind but it seems it’s always a question of time until I’m proven wrong.

    Serious providers need serious customers, and behaving like this just draws people away.

    Thanked by 1emgh
  • MoopahMoopah Member

    @mikewazar said:

    @sunnyg said:
    Having used numerous large hosts, only seen Hetzner offering unlimited traffic on their 10GE links.

    “Unlimited” billed at €1/TB :)

    Some providers charge $5-$10 per TB on overages

Sign In or Register to comment.