Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


New on LowEndTalk? Please Register and read our Community Rules.

All new Registrations are manually reviewed and approved, so a short delay after registration may occur before your account becomes active.

Supermicro X9DRD-IF onboard raid opinion

BhuvanBhuvan Member
edited September 2014 in Help

So , I was planning to configure this mobo which has onboard raid 0 1 1+0 facility , In my opinion onboard raid for 4x SSD drives should hit the marks of 2 GB/s I/O , similar to RAID CARD although i think onboard raid would not put load on CPU + mobo doesnt have to contact the raid card on a pci slot making the stuff even faster .

But what do you guys think ?

will be using 64 gigs of ram +2x E5-2620

Comments

  • You're probably right. However, I personally prefer to use LSI/Adaptec cards as you can pack more drives with them. Just imagine the I/O when you have 6x 900 GB SSD on a LSI Card w/ Cachevault add-on.

    Also +1 on using E5-2620's

  • Yea planning to provision a few under this configuration

    2xE5-2620

    64GB RAM

    4x512GB Samsung EVO pro SSD

    OnBoard RAID10

    125 IPv4

    10TB @ 1GBPS

    HostDime DC Orlando FL USA

    Free OS reloads

    @ $300/m

    I wonder if the price is good compared to market

  • i think onboard raid would not put load on CPU + mobo doesnt have to contact the raid card on a pci slot making the stuff even faster .

    Umm... How exactly do you think the onboard controller communicates with the rest of the system then?

    Onboard raid will be slower than a decent raid card.

  • will try to run a benchmark on it after my first build then will compare it with a lsi raid card variation

  • wychwych Member
    edited September 2014

    @Bhuvan said:
    will try to run a benchmark on it after my first build then will compare it with a lsi raid card variation

    On board will be slower than the add on raid card.

    Also do you have a spare motherboard/card on hand for the systems should one take a dump and you need to recover the data?

  • @wych said:
    Also do you have a spare motherboard/card on hand for the systems should one take a dump and you need to recover the data?

    Ofc spare parts will be available for immediate replacement including drives will stock on WD's blacks and Samsung evos

  • said: In my opinion onboard raid for 4x SSD drives should hit the marks of 2 GB/s I/O

    Nope. You'd be lucky if you get something over 500MB/sec

  • I guess @serverian is right waiting for your results though

  • BhuvanBhuvan Member
    edited September 2014

    @serverian Lets see , even im not sure what kind of I/O speed i'll be experiencing , it is a SATA III RAID , the onboard raid you mentioned is SATA II which is limited to 500 mb/s

  • @Bhuvan said:
    serverian Lets see , even im not sure what kind of I/O speed i'll be experiencing , it is a SATA III RAID , the onboard raid you mentioned is SATA II which is limited to 500 mb/s

    No, he's right. You'll find out soon :)

  • You are running RAID-10, on-board controller vs addon controller will make no real difference.
    Plus an addon controller is introducing a SPoF - Single Point of Failure -- for no reason.

    You also lose TRIM/garbage clean up by using raid cards -- which actually means DECREASED PERFORMANCE.

  • @Bhuvan said:
    Yea planning to provision a few under this configuration

    2xE5-2620

    64GB RAM

    4x512GB Samsung EVO pro SSD

    OnBoard RAID10

    125 IPv4

    10TB @ 1GBPS

    HostDime DC Orlando FL USA

    Free OS reloads

    @ $300/m

    I wonder if the price is good compared to market

    Good price with that overall expensive hardware config.

Sign In or Register to comment.